What are index funds?
Index funds are a form of mutual fund or ETF that track a financial market index, such as the S&P 500. Passive funds offer broad market exposure, low operating costs, and low portfolio turnover. These funds track their benchmark index regardless of market conditions.
Index funds make suitable core portfolio holdings for retirement accounts like IRAs and 401(k)s. Collective funds are Warren Buffett’s retirement savings recommendation. He suggests regular investors benefit from investing in an index fund, which offers the low cost of all S&P 500 businesses, rather than selecting individual stocks.1
How Index Funds Work
“Indexing” is passive fund management. Instead of actively engaging in stock selection and market timing, fund managers create a portfolio that matches the securities of an index. The fund mimics the index profile—the stock market as a whole or a significant segment—to match its performance.2
Most financial markets have indexes and commercial funds. The most popular U.S. index funds track the S&P 500. However, various indexes are widespread, including:
Wilshire 5000 Total Market Index, the largest U.S. equity index
MSCI EAFE Index, which includes European, Australasian, and Far Eastern stocks
Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index tracks all bonds.
The Nasdaq Composite Index includes 3,000 stocks listed on the exchange.
The DJIA includes 30 large-cap companies.
Broad-market funds track the DJIA by investing in its 30 largest publicly traded firms.
Index fund portfolios only significantly change when their benchmark indices do. The managers of a weighted index fund may periodically adjust the percentage of securities to match their weight in the benchmark. Weighting balances the impact of individual holdings in an index or portfolio.
ETFs, like index mutual funds, imitate market indexes and may be more liquid or cost-effective for some investors.
Index vs. Active Funds
Index funds are a passive investment method. As opposed to passive investment, actively managed mutual funds use a securities-picking, market-timing portfolio, as mentioned above.
Low Costs
A key benefit of ET funds over actively managed ones is a lower management expense ratio. The management expense ratio—a fund’s running expenses—includes advisor and manager compensation, transaction fees, taxes, and accounting costs.8
Index fund managers do not need research analysts or other stock-selection help because they replicate a benchmark index. Index fund managers trade assets less, saving on transaction fees and commissions. Actively managed funds have larger staffs and more transactions, raising costs.
Fund expense ratios reflect management costs and pass them on to investors. In contrast, actively managed funds charge 0.66% to 1.00%, while low-index funds charge 0.05% or less.910
Expense ratios affect fund performance. Actively managed funds with higher expense ratios generally underperform index funds in return.
Use your online brokerage account’s mutual fund or ETF screener to find available index funds.
Grab Investopedia’s special issue print edition to learn about the 10 Rules of Investing.
Better Returns?
Passive funds outperform most actively managed mutual funds, say proponents. Most mutual funds fail to surpass their benchmark or broad market index. In the five years ending Dec. 31, 2022, 87% of large-cap U.S. funds had a return below the S&P 500, as per SPIVA Scorecard data from S&P Dow Jones Indices.11
Passively managed funds don’t try to beat the market. They match market risk and return because they believe the market always wins.
Passive management usually improves performance over time. Active mutual funds perform better over shorter periods. According to the SPIVA Scorecard, only 51% of large-cap mutual funds underperformed the S&P 500 in one year. At least half beat it in the short term. Active money management applies to other categories as well. Over 35% of midcap mutual funds outperformed the S&P MidCap 400 Growth Index benchmark in a year.11
Pros
- Diversify to reduce risk
- Cheap costs
- Strong long-term returns
- Suit passive, buy-and-hold investors
- Tax cuts for investors
Cons
- Risky of market fluctuations and crashes
- Lack of adaptability
- No Humanity
- Limited gains
- Example of Index Fund
Broad-market funds have been operating since the 1970s but have grown in popularity in the past decade. The popularity of passive investing due to low costs and a long-term bull market has led to its rise. Over the past decade, Morningstar Research says investors have invested over a trillion dollars in index funds across all asset classes. Actively managed funds lost hundreds of billions during the same period.12
Vanguard chair John Bogle launched the first fund in 1976, which remains one of the finest for long-term performance and low cost. The Vanguard 500 Index Fund closely tracks the S&P 500 in composition and performance. In Q4 2023, Vanguard’s Admiral Shares (VFIAX) had a 10-year cumulative return of 204.5%, compared to the S&P 500’s 205.5%, indicating a minor tracking inaccuracy. The minimum investment is $3,000.13, and the expense ratio is 0.04%.
Top Index Funds
- Best Index Funds (Q4 2023)
- Fund Name
- Minimum Investment
- Expense Ratio
- 10-Year Mean. Annual Return
A better index or actively managed funds?
Whether passive funds are superior to actively managed funds is a joint investment debate, with both strategies having pros and cons. A comparison helps explain the differences:
Advantages of Index Funds
Passively managed index funds have lower expense ratios, resulting in cheaper costs. No analysts or active managers are needed, lowering operational costs.
Diversified funds try to replicate the performance of a given index, providing broad market exposure. Those seeking a diversified investment that reflects market trends may benefit.
Passive funds are transparent since they duplicate a market index, resulting in well-known and stable holdings.
Historical Performance: Basket funds often beat actively managed funds over time, even after fees and expenses.
Low turnover rates in commercial funds lead to lower capital gains distributions, making them more tax-efficient than actively managed funds.
We actively managed the funds’ benefits.
Active funds attempt to outperform the market, not just mirror it. Skilled fund managers may outperform the market or index.
Active managers can modify their tactics to suit market situations, safeguarding the fund from downturns or seizing short-term opportunities.
Specialized techniques: Active funds target niche investment techniques, industries, or themes that may not be featured in market indices.
Active risk management enables dynamic risk assessment and management, which is critical in turbulent or down markets.
Standard long-term investors benefit from index funds’ many benefits. Neither sort of fund is better. It mostly depends on investing goals, the environment, and preferences. Investors may also benefit from diversifying across both types of ETFs.
Index fund investing: how to start
Exchange-traded funds are accessible for new and seasoned investors. Start with this guide:
Step 1: Select an online brokerage or investment platform. Today, several online platforms include passive funds and ETFs for commission-free trading.
Open an Account: After selecting a platform, create an account. This requires supplying personal information, login credentials, and an investment goals and risk tolerance questionnaire.
Once your account is set up, you must deposit funds via bank transfer. Your initial investment relies on your finances and ambitions.
Choose broad-market funds that track market indexes like the S&P 500 or Nasdaq 100. Learn about fund performance, management costs, and indexes. Diversify your portfolio with basket funds.
Once your account is funded, you can buy shares of your favorite passive funds, or ETFs. Most platforms let you buy shares with a few clicks on their website or app.
Check your investments regularly and adjust as needed. Although collective investments are long-term investments, you should examine your portfolio periodically to ensure it meets your financial goals.
Visit Investopedia’s Best Online Brokers Guide for a comprehensive guide and further resources on online brokers. This website gives detailed information and comparisons to help you choose an investment account.
How do index ETFs work?
ETFs can be index funds. The shares in these professional financial firm-managed stock portfolios reflect a minor ownership stake in the total portfolio. For index funds, the financial institution aims to mirror the index’s performance. If the index contains 1% of a stock, the fund manager will include 1% of that stock in its portfolio.
Are index funds better than stocks?
Commercial funds monitor multi-stock portfolios. Diversification benefits investors by raising expected returns and reducing risk. Any stock can plummet sharply, but it’s less detrimental if it’s a minor part of an index.
Index Funds: Good Investments?
Most experts recommend listing funds for long-term investors. They provide a well-diversified, index-tracking portfolio at a reasonable cost. Compare diversified funds, or ETFs, to track the best index for your goals at the lowest cost.
Collective funds are risky, like other stock market investments. The fund’s value fluctuates with the index. Following an index, these funds don’t pivot to market changes, which might negatively decrease markets. Thus, such funds are typically considered suitable investments, but their suitability depends on an investor’s goals, risk tolerance, and timetable.
How Much Should an Index Fund Cost?
It typically has modest yearly costs, which have been dropping for years. The average index fund fee in 2022 will be 0.04%, with specific funds charging even less. Consider choosing the lower-cost fund if both funds closely track the same index (actively managed funds average 0.66%).
Conclusion
- Commercial funds are stock or bond portfolios that imitate financial market indices.
- Actively managed funds charge more than index funds.
- Broad-market funds invest passively.
- Collective investments replicate market risk and return, hoping the market will outperform any investment over time.
