What Does Failure To Deliver (FTD) Mean?
Failure to deliver (FTD) occurs when one party in a trading contract (shares, futures, options, or forward contracts) fails to deliver. Buyers (long positions) don’t have enough money to take delivery and pay at settlement, causing such failures.
Failure can also occur if the seller (the short position) does not own all or any of the underlying assets needed at settlement and cannot deliver.
Understanding Delivery Failure
Both parties to a trade must transfer cash or assets before settlement. If the transaction is not settled, one party fails to deliver. Technical issues in the clearinghouse’s settlement process can also cause delivery failures.
Failure to deliver is critical in naked short selling. In naked short selling, an individual agrees to sell a stock they and their broker do not own and cannot prove their ownership. The average person cannot trade this way. However, a proprietary trader risking their capital for a trading firm may be able to. Though illegal, some individuals or institutions may believe the company they short will go out of business, allowing them to profit in a naked short sale without accountability.
The failure to deliver creates “phantom shares” in the market, which may dilute the stock price. Thus, the buyer on the other side of such trades may own paper shares that do not exist.
Failure to Deliver Events’ Chain Reactions
Trades that don’t settle due to non-delivery cause several issues. Shares and derivatives can fail to deliver.
In forward contracts, a short position’s failure to deliver can cause significant issues for the extended post. These contracts often involve large amounts of assets relevant to the extended position’s business operations, causing this issue.
A business may pre-sell an item they do not yet have. Supplier shipment delays often cause this. The supplier was late so the seller couldn’t deliver. The buyer may cancel the order, leaving the seller with a lost sale, useless inventory, and a late supplier. The buyer won’t get what they need. The seller can buy the goods at higher prices in the market.
The same goes for financial and commodity instruments. Failure to deliver in one part of the chain can further affect stakeholders.
Delivery failures rose during the 2008 financial crisis. Sellers failed to surrender securities sold on time, similar to check kiting. They delayed buying securities at a lower delivery price.
Conclusion
- Failure to deliver (FTD) means missing trading obligations.
- Buyers lack cash; sellers lack goods.
- These obligations are calculated at trade settlement.
- Selling short naked or in derivatives contracts can lead to delivery failure.